On one hand, the Old Lady could love to welcome Pogba back to Turin and field him alongside Cristiano Ronaldo.
Yet, in De Ligt, they have a player with the potential to become one of the best defenders in world football.
Meanwhile ESPN FC pundit Alejandro Moreno has had his say on a possible swap deal involving De Ligt and Pogba.
He said: “Well that’s assuming that you actually have a player in mind and player in place that is going to take that position in the middle of midfield for Manchester United because, well, De Ligt yeah would solve a problem in the backline alongside [Harry] Maguire but then you still have a Pogba-sized hole in that middle of midfield.
“You have Bruno Fernandes who has done a wonderful job but you also have to then address that situation.